Mindset
Ideas gleaned from an article published in the ASCA Newsletter
entitled: “Learning is winning and success is doing everything just right.”
Thanks to my membership in
the American Swimming Coaches Association (ASCA) I was introduced to a new
concept in teaching, learning and motivation.
Several years ago I received a newsletter from ASCA that introduced me
to a new way of looking at teaching/coaching, learning, success and
winning. The article in the ASCA
Newsletter was based on a book written by Dr
Carol Dweck of Stanford University.
In her book called Mindset, she writes that to be
successful and sustain motivation everyone needs to develop, or cultivate what
is called a “growth mindset”.
In her book Dr Dweck
proposes that there are two types of mindsets, a fixed mindset and a growth
mindset. A fixed mindset person is
defined as those who “…believe their basic qualities, such as intelligence and
abilities are fixed, and can't be developed. They also believe that talent
alone creates success, and see effort as a sign of weakness rather than as a
positive element of life needed to reach one's full potential.” A growth mindset person is defined as,
“…people [who] believe they can develop their brain, abilities, and
talent”. In Dr Dweck’s research she has
found that the person who cultivates a growth mindset has “…a love for
learning, a drive for growth and a resilience that is essential for great
accomplishments”. The chart on the next
page illustrates the differences between those who have a fixed mindset and
those who have a growth mindset.
According to Dr Dweck, those
who believe that their success is based on their innate ability are thought to have
a “fixed” theory of intelligence, or in other words a fixed mind set. Those who
believe that their success is based on their individual hard work, training,
and commitment are said to have a “growth” an “incremental” theory of
intelligence (a growth mindset). The two types of mindsets are defined as:
1. Fixed mindset:
The belief that we’re born with a fixed amount of intelligence and
ability. People operating in the fixed mindset are prone to avoiding challenges
and failures, thereby robbing themselves of a life rich experience and learning
2. Growth Mindset: The belief that with practice,
perseverance, and effort, people have limitless potential to learn and grow.
People operating in the growth mindset tackle challenges with aplomb,
unconcerned with making mistakes or being embarrassed, focusing instead on the
process of growth.
“In order to excel, you must be completely dedicated to your
chosen sport. You must also be prepared to work hard and be willing to accept
constructive criticism. Without one-hundred percent dedication, you won't be
able to do this.” Willie Mays
A large part of our “mindset”,
whether it is a fixed or growth Mindset, will be influenced by constructive
criticism. As coaches we must be willing to teach in such a manner that helps
the student-athlete to learn how to handle the stress of training, the demands
of learning and the characteristics of a successful swimmer. When we teach/coach,
we need to communicate things in a positive manner so that the student-athlete
will think in a positive manner. For example, instead of correcting
student-athlete’s technique by saying “don’t do that.” We might try saying
something like this, “your freestyle was very good but to make it belter I
think you should work on the catching the water a little sooner after you enter
the water while keeping the elbow a little higher in the water with your armpit
open a little more to the bottom of the pool”.
We can help our student-athletes
develop a growth mind set by teaching in a positive matter and by setting up
training situations to motivate and help the student-athlete embrace challenges
and learn from them. We can give them cues on which to focus in any given set
and then, after the set was performed ask them for feedback, about what they
learned during the set. Have them give you three things they learned while
performing the set. We can help them further to develop a growth mind set by
expecting them tell us what they learned and how they can make it better the next
time they have the opportunity to the given swim or set.
Here is a sample
Mindset Questionnaire:
Mindset Questionnaire
_____ 1.
There are just some things I’ll never be good at.
_____ 2.
When I make a mistake, I try to learn from it.
_____ 3.
When others do better than me, I feel threatened.
_____ 4. I
enjoy getting out of my comfort zone.
_____ 5.
When I show others I’m smart or talented, I feel successful.
_____ 6. I
feel inspired by the success of others.
_____ 7. I
feel good when I can do something others cannot.
_____ 8.
It’s possible to change how intelligent you are.
_____ 9. You
shouldn’t have to try to be smart-you just are or you aren’t.
_____
10. I enjoy taking on a new challenge or
task with which I am unfamiliar.
Odd-numbered statements
indicate a fixed mindset, Even-numbered statements illustrate a growth min
If you want to test
yourself click on the following link and take the Minset quiz.
Which are you? Thank
you to Dr Carol Dweck for her work on Mindset. In the following weeks I will
blog more about this great theory and tool. More on Mindset later.
I really like how easily this concept is presented by Carol, though the repercussions for the reader (and your athletes, if you pass this philosophy on) is deep and long lasting. These ideas are (per Hannula) not ‘new’; and in fact are steeped deeply in Zen philosophy which is ancient. Indeed, Don Swartz (a Zen practitioner of some renown in our own coaching ranks) advocated this thinking many years ago. The diagram is particularly useful for those of us who tend to think in three dimensions...thanks for sharing this. It’s good stuff!
ReplyDeleteThank you Russ for your feedback and insight.
Delete